Tuesday, December 20, 2011

Living in the Lucky Country Doesn't Come Cheap

I recently wrote for the UK Telegraph on the rising cost of expat life in the land down under. This is a contentious issue and one which is stirring up opinion on both sides of the fence - those who agree and those who emphatically do not.

I've posted the article below and encourage you to join in the discussion at the end and share your own views on this polarising subject.

Only a few days ago, I went to the local supermarket searching out some chilli peppers for the week ahead. At nearly 43 Australian dollars per kilo (£28), I chose to walk out empty-handed as, once again, prices in the food shops were spiralling out of control. A week before, banana prices had been rocketing.

Photo credit: martinhoward

This capped off a week in which it cost me more than $90 to fill my car (up from $60 several months ago), over $25 to buy a reasonable bottle of red wine (up from $15 not long ago), about $350 to pay an extraordinarily high electricity bill for the last quarter, and a little under $6,000 to pay an excessive monthly mortgage payment on a fairly regular size house.

All of the basic commodities – bread, fruit, milk – are more expensive than I can previously remember, the cost of petrol has risen, house prices continue to climb, and the only saving grace is that interest rates seem to be dropping whilst salaries remain high, even if I feel constantly penniless and barely scraping by.

Perhaps I’m just whinging, as all British expats here allegedly do, but expat life in Sydney has grown far less affordable over the past five years, which make it far more appealing to be some place else.

We’re often told that Europe is sinking in a quagmire of recession and economic turmoil, whilst Australians enjoy the benefits of a booming recession-free economy combined with a superior quality of life lived under a perpetual sun and in the great outdoors. Thousands of Brits continue to make their way to Australia and Sydney each year safe in this knowledge, and there is no shortage in the number of surveys and reports touting Sydney’s obvious desirability.

The Mercer 2011 Quality of Living Survey, for example, which compares 221 cities based on 39 criteria, ranked Sydney as the 11th most liveable city in the world, whilst the Economist Intelligence Unit’s Global Liveability Report rated Sydney as the sixth most liveable city in the world. This contrasts starkly with another recent survey in The Guardian which named the UK as having the worst quality of life in Europe.

It’s therefore no great surprise that Brits continue to flock to Sydney in large numbers, but what I’m curious to know is whether the true financial cost of living a new life in the land down under is understood by these new immigrants and whether economics, rather than emotional reasons, might eventually drive them back home.

A spate of media commentary in recent weeks has focused on those Brits leaving Australia and returning to the homeland. Even the Mayor of London, addressing a lunch gathering of Australian business executives, mentioned the ping-pong Poms who are turning their backs on Australia because, despite the endless sunshine and chance to live by the coast, life is generally dull, they miss friends and family, lack any real sense of belonging, would prefer a less macho culture, and want more of the history commonly found in Europe.

Photo credit: Robert van Dijk

What the commentary doesn’t focus on is the exorbitant cost of living in Australia, particularly in Sydney, compared to prices in Britain, which immigration analysts suggest is the likely factor fuelling the trend for expats to return home.

So what are the options for expats like myself, struggling with the high cost of life in the sun but reluctant to give up this improved way of living for purely financial reasons? Do I move to another Australian city where the prices might be cheaper but the quality of life might also be less? Perhaps return to the Old Dart where the cost of living might be reduced but where I might give up so much more in the process? Or remain in Sydney where I can live close to the beach but pay dearly for it in the long run?

After almost nine years away, I still experience a profound pull back to the UK, to be near my family and friends, to witness the distinct change in seasons, enjoy polite conversation, green fields, and of course the quality TV. I suppose I could always head back for a short while, keeping my Australian citizenship as a back-up, leaving me free to return one day if, and when, the sky-high living costs subside.

Yet, in a recent interview with the BBC News Magazine, the radio DJ and ping-pong Pom himself, Jono Coleman, summed it up best for me. He posed the question that when you’re broke, hard up and cash strapped, where would you rather be? Sitting in a park in the rain in London or in a park in a sunny Sydney looking out at the ocean?

Although financially tougher, the latter option still seems infinitely better to me.

This article originally appeared in the Telegraph's Finance section on 8 December 2011 - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/offshorefinance/8942489/The-true-cost-of-expat-living-in-Australia.html

Are you a Sydneysider experiencing the rising cost of living? Do you live elsewhere in the wider world and are encountering similar issues? Or are you in the UK and very glad to be there right now?

Sign up for regular email updates. It's easy and free.




20 comments:

Kym Hamer said... Add Reply

I moved from Melbourne to London in January 2004 so I am coming up to 8 years away from Oz. I visited last Christmas and was horrified at how expensive things had become: over $50 for 3 of us to go to the movies. Not much change from $20 to get bread, milk, cheese at the supermarket.

On previous trips back (2005 and then 2007) I don't remember feeling this way. In 2007, we hired a car, filled it with petrol often, ate out a lot, drove around to visit attractions etc and felt it was 'good value' when compared with London. Last Christmas I tried to tell myself that maybe I had become one of those expats who knows every discounted way to do things in London and combined with the not as good exchange rate (you got $2.50 for a pound in 2004 vs $1.52 at the moment), that was making things feel worse.

But really I just came home to London shaking my head a little and wondering 'When did Australia get so expensive?'

Jackscottbodrum said... Add Reply

I tend to take these various quality of life indexes with a large bucket of salt. It really depends what matters to you, what you spend your cash on and how you live your life. I've often seen cities like Zurich and Oslo way up there on the list. I've nothing against the Swiss or the Norwegians and these cities are great places to visit but I'm sure I'd be bored silly after a few weeks. I've read that the cost of living is high in Australia but, as you say, there are compensations. When Liam visited a few years back, he wanted to stay (that was before he met me, obviously!).

Aisha Isabel Ashraf said... Add Reply

That's scarily expensive, considering the Australian and Canadian dollar are almost at parity. I know I moan about the cost of dairy, etc. here in Canada, but bloody hell, I know my money goes further than that! Thank God you don't have kids! $40 fills our petrol-tank... 
My husband may be involved in the preparations for the Commonwealth Games on the Gold Coast, but with those kinds of costs I reckon me 'n' the kids will be staying here and flying over for visits only!
Guess you're gonna have to type faster to stay on top of the bills :-/
Christmas cheer from over here!

A

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

It’s funny what you accept as normal. Sure my car is bigger than it used to be (therefore more expensive to fill up) and no, I don’t regularly buy chilli peppers at the local store (but the price still floored me). I found this article the other day - http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-12-14/aussie-consumers-ripped-off-overcharged-report/3730444 - in case you think I’m making this up and having a good ole whinge!

You’ll have to say ‘hi’ when you come over. The Cth Games will be a major event for the Gold Coast.

Christmas cheer from all the way over here too!

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

I often see Vienna up there at the top of the list and, lovely as it is, I wouldn’t get my kicks out of living there so definitely agree with you. Maybe the high costs here will drop over time, especially if Europe drags us down into a global recession (will someone please stand up and sort that mess out!).

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

We almost left our home countries at the same time. I left a few months earlier but headed Canada-way.

I remember visiting Australia when I first met my wife 11 years ago. It was $3 to each Pound. Groceries were cheap. Wine was cheaper. I felt like it was a ‘value for money’ place (maybe that was simply down to the favourable exchange rate at the time). It’s definitely pricier now – two of us hit the movies for $35 so we go to ‘cheap night’ midweek. We try to drive the car less. We grow our own veggies. We’ve minimised our debt. But we’ve noticed our everyday outgoings climbing and we wonder what we’re doing wrong.

Sure I could live in a different part of Oz (or even Sydney) but the cost of moving there (and likely the lower wages) will negate any benefit I might have made (perhaps).

I sincerely promise I’m not having a good ole whinge ;-) I just wonder if the reason some expats are leaving here is because of the high costs…???

Mysydneyparislife said... Add Reply

Great post and your observations are consistent with what we've experienced moving from Northern Beaches at the end of 2010 to the UK this year. We've been hugely and pleasantly surprised by how (relatively) inexpensive basics are here -- in Sydney we thought we were doing well if we found bread at 2 for $5.00 while here we usually get it for 89p and sometime less! So much of the food items are cheaper here, though we're wondering if heating costs will hit us hard - so far that's not the case though.

When my late husband and I left Connecticut for Sydney in 1995 and 'went local' a couple years later, many American friends questioned our sanity as we gave up some U.S. financial plusses (including corporate retirement programs, etc.). We ended up explaining that some choices are matters of the heart and life is just not always about the m-word, money. We chose Australia for many, many reasons despite the financial situation being a relative 'negative' in terms of what we 'gave up' in the U.S. -- but we got so much more, in so many other ways, in Australia.

Having said all that, I also believe life is about phases and stages ... a decision to relocate for me is a combination of many different factors that come together at a point in time. Maybe there are other forces at play in your life at the moment -- in addition to these financial observations -- that will make it 'right' for you to move. Or not! I think the heart will know what to do when the time comes.

Wishing you all the best, and hope the sun comes out for Christmas! Our former neighbours in Manly have been complaining about the wet weather.

Cheers.

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

Hi!

Great to hear the perspectives of a fellow Northern Beaches (past) resident and I agree that Australia has so much to offer – experiences, opportunities, way of life. If we need to move, we’ll know it. If not, we’ll carry on enjoying life in our small part of the world.

Thanks for the Xmas best wishes. Yes, the sun has momentarily disappeared so we may be getting a colder festive period after all. I’m sure it won’t last.

Thanks :)

Kym Hamer said... Add Reply

Russell, I think it's probably a combination of the surprise at the cost of living combined with the disappointment that life is not all 'Ramsay Street and Summer Bay'. Australia has its advantages but I find it too out of step with the rest of the world and a little provincial in its outlook as a result. Fine for a holiday but let's face it, I wouldn't want to live my life on Koh Samui either

I think it surprises people that community is not easy to find either and I've heard returning expats say that Australians were not as friendly and helpful as they expected. You don't fall over people the same way you do here (well in London anyway) and expats are not as rife so rather than finding open arms and a an understanding 'shoulder' when the going gets tough, you are more likely to get a 'she'll be right'.

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

But would you want to live on Ramsay Street next to Jim? (is he even still there!)

I’ve struggled with the ‘out of stepness’ and the outlook on the world. I was also surprised myself to find Aussies not quite as friendly on their home turf as I expected – happy to chat to you in the workplace or at a bar, but not so willing to invite you round their homes for dinner or try to help you through a particular situation unique to your move here. I’ve had many ‘she’ll be rights’ and ‘toughen ups’. The complete contrast with Canada has been interesting. Canadians were generally helpful and forthcoming, the expat community was widespread yet close-knit, and the country was connected to the world and well informed in its outlook. A very different experience for different reasons.

Have a fab Xmas in London and please give it a hug from me!

Padreralpha said... Add Reply

We have been living in Sydney for 8 years. The massive increase in prices for groceries, restaurants, petrol crept up on us.
We were in Florence this year and ordered a coffee... It was real coffee and cheaper than a cup of coffee you would get here... We started comparing prices and it hit us. Sydney has grown too big for its shoes.

Padreralpha said... Add Reply

I buy a sourdough loaf at the local bakery for Aud 7.50!!!

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

I recently heard from a friend who had left Perth to move back to Italy and who told me that they thought prices were now cheaper there.  He felt that eating out was cheaper - food, coffees, drinks.  Yes, perhaps Sydney is getting ahead of itself a bit?

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

Wow, that's impressive.  My chilli excursion was my favourite.  I do believe they were having a bad week but $43/kilo shocked me, even if I did only want a handful ;-)

Dan Teague said... Add Reply

Hi Russell - long time, no speak.

Interesting blog.


Whilst I suspect the cost of living is a consideration for some expats, I agree that most probably have other reasons for choosing or staying in a location.  I think that rising cost is the price you pay for living in a (pseudo) capital city.  I spend a lot of time in Zurich and the cost of living there is extortionate - even more so due to the exchange rate vs. £ / Euro.  Property tends to be the killer - all supply and demand driven - and highly varied as to what you get for your money.  

For example, in London rents can be >£1000 per month for a 1 bedroom flat, in Zurich that'll get you next to nothing, whilst back in Amazingstoke that'll get you 4/5 bedrooms.  Yes, salaries are proportionately higher but the cost of getting (re)established are significant and where in a country you settle is just as important.

Unless you've got a property in the UK or a big lump of capital, I think returning could be an expensive option.  Plus it's raining at the moment :)

Kelly Hutchison said... Add Reply

I agree that Australia has become so expensive, I emigrated to Sydney from the UK in 2009 and couldn't get over the price of consumables there, it took me a long while to adjust to paying those prices and I did alot of converting to pounds until I had to stop as it upset me too much.   I then took to buying alot of things online as it was cheaper than buying in Australia,  they definitely need to become flexible on allowing more competition into the Australian retail market to make it more competitive.  Saying all of that, I had to put into perspective that I was earning double my UK wage and I was saving alot more money than I could ever save in the UK so there were some positives! 

I am now back in the UK and there are some things here that are a rip off such as train travel, it cost me £45 to get to London in peak hour, train fares from January are going up around 6% while most salaries only went up @2.5%, some costs are just not sustainable for some people, 2012 for me is going to be a very interesting year while I adjust to life in my own country!





 
 

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

Hi Kelly, thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment on ISOALLO!

I also stopped converting my money a few years back as it proved unhelpful. And I tend to buy most of my gifts, books, etc. online - and typically from the UK and/or the US as I find them much cheaper there, plus I often find free shipping deals along the way.  I could pay on average $35 for a new release novel here but only pay $15 online for the same book.

I'm realising that some things are pricey wherever you choose to live.  I'd forgotten about the train fares in the UK (that is so pricey!) and the poor salaries there.  My folks are often surprised at how much I earn here compared to the same job in the UK so, whilst I whinge about high property prices and groceries here, I need to remember some of the costly negatives back in Blighty!

Hope to see you over here again :)

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

Hi Dan - very good to hear from you, young man. Hope all is well in your neck of the woods!

I remember Zurich prices from a couple of trips there back in the day.  But that's an insane price to be paying for rent there.  Still, would you take that over the 4/5 bed in Basingrad?  I think so!

Supply and demand is the killer here too, which is keeping things riding high when all signs say it should be otherwise.

Unfortunately, there is no property in the UK or a big lump of capital there for me :(  Plus I'm not sure I like the sound of that rain right now...  keep me posted on those property prices ;)

Kevin Cooper said... Add Reply

I moved from England to New Zealand in 2001 when I left the Navy, spending 4 years living in Invercargill before getting another job in Lauceston in Tasmania.  This is the best place I have ever lived, and I've lived and stayed all ovre the world,  The town is charming and friendly and just the right size.  Big enough to be able to get anything, but small enough to be quiet. The lifestyle is marvellous, so much more peaceful than the frantic hell of Britain.  It took a while to get used to, but now I am Aussified, got the certificate and passport to prove it.  I would rather have root canal without drugs than go back "home".  When I do go home to see family and friends, by the second week I'm ropable and want to come home.

Russell V J Ward said... Add Reply

Hi Kevin, thanks for stopping by. I have to agree with you that Tassie and Launceston are amazing places. I was lucky enough to be there last year and had such a great time exploring the city and taking trips to places such as Cradle Mountain (a personal favourite of mine) and then on to Bicheno and the Bay of Fires and so on. Don’t go having any root canals but do go on enjoying life in that special place. Hope to see you over here again sometime soon. Cheers.

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More
To contact me about writing or advertising opportunities, email mail@russellvjward.com